Can you just... try harder?
So, does telling learners to “try harder” actually work? A Waterloo study put that message on screen 30 minutes into a recorded lecture. Viewers who saw it said they paid more attention and drifted off less, and the boost to what they remembered was small but there.
It's a Thursday afternoon, period five, somewhere around 2014. I've got a Year 9 class, we're three slides into the reactivity series, and thirty teenagers have collectively decided that potassium is somebody else's problem. So I do what every teacher in the history of teaching has done. I put the board pen down, wait for a bit of quiet, and say, "Right. This next bit is really important, so I need everyone to really concentrate."
Did it work? Honestly, I have no idea. A few heads came up. Someone at the back sat up a bit straighter, although that might have been because I was looking directly at him. I always assumed it was the classroom equivalent of telling a toddler to calm down: very satisfying to say, and almost certainly useless.
These days I spend most of my working life thinking about online learning, where there is no board pen to put down and nobody to make eye contact with. There's just a learner, a 45-minute recorded lecture, and a phone that is definitely, absolutely, face down on the desk. So here's the question. If I can't stand at the front and tell people to concentrate, would a message on the screen do the same job? Does telling someone to "try harder" actually do anything, or is it just something we say to make ourselves feel better?
As luck would have it, a team from the University of Waterloo in Canada (Derek Albert, Jackie Heitzner and Daniel Smilek) has just tested exactly that. Who knew my Year 9 crowd control was worth a peer-reviewed paper?
They ran two experiments. In both, people watched the same 45-minute recorded lecture on, and I promise I'm not making this up, sleep. Circadian rhythms, stages of sleep, what happens when you don't get enough of it. The ideal topic for keeping an audience awake. Nobody was allowed to take notes, so the quiz at the end would only show what had stuck in their heads. Every few minutes the video paused and asked how they were getting on. In the first experiment, it asked how much they were paying attention, on a slider from 0 to 100. In the second, it asked about mind wandering, split into two kinds: drifting off on purpose, and drifting off without meaning to.
About 30 minutes in, the video paused and half of the group saw this message: "Now, please TRY HARDER to learn from the last 15 min of the lecture." (A direct quote, including the obnoxious caps lock). The other half just got a polite "please press to continue". That's it. No rewards, no gold stars, no threat of a detention. The first experiment used 113 psychology students at Waterloo, doing it for course credit. The second used 100 adults recruited online and paid £7, with an average age of about 33, so a bit closer to the people most of us design for.
What did they find?
A quick health warning first. Most of these results come from people rating their own attention, so take them as ballpark figures. I'll come back to why that matters.
In the first experiment, the "try harder" group's attention went from about 57 out of 100 before the message to about 64 after it. The control group stayed exactly where they were (47 before, 46 after). By the final third of the lecture, the try harder group were rating their attention well above the control group. They also reckoned they spent less time on other things, like their phones or another browser tab: about 35% of the time, compared with 51% for the control group. Of course, the control group estimated they spent around half of a lecture they had signed up for doing something else. Sound familiar?
But here's the catch. When it came to the quiz, the message made no difference to how much people remembered from the last 15 minutes. Their brains said they were paying more attention, but this didn't translate into more learning.
So the team tweaked things for the second experiment. They wrote better quiz questions and told the control group that there were only 15 minutes left as well, to make the comparison fairer. This time, after the message, the try harder group's deliberate mind wandering dropped from 16 to 9 out of 100, and their accidental mind wandering dropped from 24 to 17. The control group barely moved on either. I find the second one the most interesting. You'd expect "try harder" to stop people choosing to drift off, but it also seemed to reduce the drifting they weren't choosing.
And the learning? This time there was a hint of something. The try harder group scored about 59% on questions from the final 15 minutes, up from 55% on the section before. The control group went the other way, from 60% down to 53%. Neither change was big enough to count on its own, but the difference between the two patterns was. So it's a small, slightly wobbly, "probably something" result.
There's a nice little twist too. In the second experiment, the control group were simply told there were 15 minutes left, and they also said they upped their effort. Psychologists call this the end-spurt effect: we all perk up a bit when we can see the finish line. The "try harder" message still beat it, though.
Why would a single sentence work at all? The authors suggest that most of us hold a bit of attention in reserve. We rarely give a task everything we've got, and a direct nudge invites us to dip into that spare tank. Interestingly, both groups rated their motivation about the same, so the message seems to have tapped into effort people already had.
Now the limitations, and there are a few. Being told to try harder and then being asked "how hard are you trying?" is a fairly leading combination, so some of the self-reported boost may just be people being polite. The memory effect was small and only showed up in one of the two experiments. It was one lecture, on one topic, in one sitting, with no note-taking (which is not how anyone actually watches a lecture). And they only showed the message once, so we've no idea whether it wears off if you use it every ten minutes.
What does this tell us about learning design?
I'll admit it's slightly humbling. After decades of instructional design theory, adaptive platforms and AI tutors, one of the cheapest interventions on the table is a sentence your nan could have written. But I think there's a real lesson here.
We often design online courses as if good content will hold attention all by itself. It won't. Attention drops over time in recorded lectures, and this study suggests that a well-timed, direct nudge can claw some of it back for free. If you're building a long video or an e-learning module, it's worth putting something in at the point where attention usually sags (around the two-thirds mark seems a good bet) that tells learners plainly that what's coming matters and asks them to lean in.
I'd be careful not to overdo it, though. Put "TRY HARDER" on every other slide and it'll become wallpaper, like cookie banners and "this call may be recorded for training purposes". And I wouldn't swap it for the things with stronger evidence behind them. The authors themselves point to earlier research showing that short quizzes dotted through a recorded lecture reduce mind wandering and improve learning. A nudge plus a quick question is probably a much better combination than either alone.
Which brings me back to that Year 9 class and the reactivity series. Was my "really concentrate" useless after all? Probably not. It might well have nudged a few of them into their spare tank for ten minutes. Whether they remembered that potassium reacts violently with water is another matter, although to be fair, nobody ever forgets that one once they've seen it.
And if you've made it this far and your mind has started wandering towards what's for tea: now, please TRY HARDER to read the last line.
Go on, have a look at the full paper. It's open access.
Read the full paper: Simple calls to increase effort influence attention, mind wandering, and learning during online lectures (Albert, Heitzner and Smilek, 2026, Scientific Reports)